Average return
The average return is how much money a strategy makes per year on average. It's the first number everyone looks at, and it's the worst place to stop. Without the risk, it's just a number that looks good on a slide.
Volatility is risk
Volatility is how much the value swings up and down. A strategy that jumps 30% in a day is risky whether or not it wins. Most of quant work is really just the search for good returns that don't make your stomach drop.